Start with what the law needs your software to do: Making Tax Digital for VAT, and for Income Tax if your qualifying income is over the threshold. Then compare price, bank feeds, payroll and how the product fits the way you keep records.
Accounting software keeps your business records and, for many small businesses, sends returns to HMRC. The accounting software comparison sets out prices and features for 7 products side by side. This guide explains what to check before you choose. HMRC does not recommend any product or provider.
What the law needs your software to do
If your business is registered for VAT, you must keep digital records and send VAT returns using software that works with Making Tax Digital for VAT.
Sole traders and landlords must use Making Tax Digital for Income Tax once their qualifying income passes the threshold:
| From | Qualifying income over |
|---|---|
| 6 April 2026 | £50,000 |
| 6 April 2027 | £30,000 |
| 6 April 2028 | £20,000 |
Qualifying income is your gross self-employment and property income added together. The Making Tax Digital guide for sole traders explains how it is worked out.
For Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, your software, or your agent's, must:
- Create, store and correct digital records of your self-employment and property income and expenses.
- Send quarterly updates to HMRC. These are summaries of income and expenses. They are not tax returns.
- Add any other income you have and submit your tax return by 31 January after the tax year.
Choose your software before you sign up for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax. You still submit a Self Assessment return for the tax year before you start.
Quarterly update deadlines
With standard update periods, which follow the tax year, each update is cumulative from 6 April:
| Update period | Deadline |
|---|---|
| 6 April to 5 July | 7 August |
| 6 April to 5 October | 7 November |
| 6 April to 5 January | 7 February |
| 6 April to 5 April | 7 May |
Check the software supports the update periods you use, standard or calendar.
Types of software
HMRC describes 2 types.
- Software that creates digital records. You link it to your business bank account to import transactions, scan receipts and invoices, or type entries in by hand. These products usually handle quarterly updates and the tax return.
- Bridging software. It connects to records you already keep, such as a spreadsheet, and sends the submissions to HMRC.
You can use more than one product, for example one for records and quarterly updates and another for the tax return. You can only use one product for each separate submission, so a landlord cannot split property updates across 2 products. If you use more than one, check they work together.
What to compare
| Feature | What to check |
|---|---|
| Price | The monthly price after any introductory offer ends, and whether VAT is added |
| Free plan | Limits on transactions, users or features |
| Bank feeds | Whether it connects to your bank and imports transactions each day |
| Income sources | Self-employment, property, or both, and any you expect to add |
| VAT | Whether it sends VAT returns to HMRC and supports your VAT scheme |
| Payroll | Whether payroll is included, an add-on, or not offered |
| Invoices | Whether invoices show everything a valid invoice needs and can take card payments |
| Agent access | Whether your accountant can log in, and whether it allows more than one agent |
| HMRC Assist | Whether it is built in to give feedback and highlight errors on your tax return |
HMRC says free products exist for people with simple tax affairs, with limits such as a cap on the number of transactions.
Records you must keep
Whatever software you choose, it has to hold the records the law needs.
Sole traders keep records of all sales, income and business expenses, plus VAT records if registered and PAYE records if they employ people. Keep them for at least 5 years after the 31 January deadline for the tax year. Example from gov.uk: if you sent your 2022/23 return by 31 January 2024, keep the records until at least the end of January 2029.
Limited companies keep records of all money received and spent, assets, debts owed and owed to the company, stock at the year end, and goods bought and sold. Keep them for 6 years from the end of the last financial year they relate to, or longer in some cases. HMRC can fine a company £3,000, or a director can be disqualified, for not keeping accounting records.
Extra records under traditional accounting
If you use traditional accounting in place of the cash basis, your software also needs to record:
- What you are owed but have not received yet.
- What you have committed to spend but not paid yet, such as an invoice you have received.
- The value of stock and work in progress at the end of the accounting period.
- Your year-end bank balances.
- How much you invested in the business in the year, and how much you took out for your own use.
Software that tracks unpaid invoices and bills, and stock, makes these figures easier to produce.
If records are lost
If you cannot replace lost, stolen or destroyed records, you must do your best to provide figures, and tell HMRC when you file whether they are estimated or provisional. Cloud software with backups reduces that risk, and so does saving receipts as you go.
If you are registered for VAT
You already use software for VAT. Check whether that product also works with Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, or whether a new product can handle your VAT as well. The VAT registration guide explains when you need to register.
Worked example
Example: Dan is a self-employed electrician with £38,000 of turnover and a buy-to-let flat with £9,000 of rent in 2025/26.
- His qualifying income is £38,000 plus £9,000, which is £47,000.
- HMRC checks his 2025/26 tax return to decide whether he must use Making Tax Digital from April 2027.
- £47,000 is over £30,000, so he needs compatible software from 6 April 2027.
- He needs software that handles both self-employment and property income, or 2 products that work together.
- He is not VAT registered, so VAT returns are not a deciding feature for him.
- He compares the price after any offer ends, the bank feed with his bank, and whether his accountant can log in.
A checklist before you sign up
Work through these points for each product on your shortlist, and note the answers side by side.
- Check whether and when Making Tax Digital for Income Tax applies to you.
- List your income sources, including any you plan to add, such as letting a property.
- Check the product is on HMRC's software finder for Making Tax Digital.
- Check it handles VAT returns if you are registered.
- Check the bank feed works with your bank.
- Work out the cost over 12 months, after any introductory offer.
- Check how you export your records if you change product later.
- Ask your accountant which products they can work with.
Changing software
If your income sources change, check your software supports the new source. Example: a landlord starting a trade needs software that handles self-employment income as well as property. Keep old records you are required to keep, even after you move to a new product.
Help with your records
The comparison of accounting software shows prices, offers and features. The self-employed expenses guide covers what you can claim. If you would like an accountant to keep your records and file your returns, Buzz Accounting offers that service.
Questions
Do I have to use accounting software?
If your business is registered for VAT, yes. You must keep digital records and send VAT returns using software that works with Making Tax Digital for VAT. Sole traders and landlords must also use compatible software for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax once their qualifying income is over £50,000 from 6 April 2026, over £30,000 from 6 April 2027 and over £20,000 from 6 April 2028. Qualifying income is gross self-employment and property income added together, taken from the tax return for the previous tax year. Example: a sole trader with £22,000 of turnover and £10,000 of rent on the 2025/26 return has qualifying income of £32,000, so needs compatible software from 6 April 2027. Choose the software before you sign up.
Can I keep using a spreadsheet?
Yes. HMRC accepts bridging software, which connects to records kept in a spreadsheet or another accounting tool and sends your submissions to HMRC. Make sure the product you choose sends quarterly updates and submits the tax return, or pair it with a second product for the return. You can use more than one product as long as they work together, but only one product for each separate submission, so a landlord cannot split property updates across 2 products. Example: a landlord keeps rent and costs in a spreadsheet, links bridging software to it, and sends all 4 quarterly updates, due 7 August, 7 November, 7 February and 7 May, through that one product. The tax return for the year is then due by 31 January.
Is there free software?
Yes. HMRC says free products are available for people with simple tax affairs, with limits on how they can be used, such as a cap on the number of transactions. Before choosing one, confirm it supports every income source you have, self-employment, property or both, and any you expect to add, and that it handles quarterly updates and the tax return. Every product in HMRC's software finder has been through its recognition process. Example: a landlord with one flat and 12 rent receipts a year has few transactions, while a café with daily card takings has hundreds. For a paid product, work out the cost over 12 months after any introductory offer ends, and set it against the free product's limits.
Does HMRC recommend a product?
No. HMRC lists compatible software in its software finder, and every product listed has been through HMRC's recognition process, but HMRC does not recommend any product or provider. The finder asks a few questions and gives a personalised list, and you can search for software you already use to see whether it works with Making Tax Digital for Income Tax. Compare the products on the list against your own needs: your income sources, VAT returns if you are registered, bank feeds, payroll, agent access for your accountant, and whether HMRC Assist is built in to highlight errors on your tax return. Ask your accountant which products they work with before you sign up.
How long must I keep records?
Sole traders keep records for at least 5 years after the 31 January submission deadline for the tax year. Limited companies keep them for 6 years from the end of the last financial year they relate to, or longer if they cover more than one accounting period, relate to an asset expected to last more than 6 years, or the Company Tax Return was sent late. Example from gov.uk: a sole trader who sent the 2022/23 return by 31 January 2024 keeps the records until at least the end of January 2029. If you change software, export your old records first and keep them for the full period. HMRC can fine a company £3,000, or a director can be disqualified, for not keeping accounting records.