businesshelper.uk

How to choose payroll software for a small employer

GuidePublished 19 November 2026

Payroll software must work out tax and National Insurance, report each payment to HMRC on or before pay day, and handle statutory pay. HMRC's Basic PAYE Tools is free for employers with fewer than 10 employees. Paid products add payslips, pension links and more.

The payroll software comparison sets out prices and features for 6 products. This guide explains what payroll software has to do, and what to check before you choose.

What payroll software must do

Every time you pay employees, use your payroll software to:

  1. Record their pay, including salary or wages and any other pay.
  2. Calculate deductions such as tax and National Insurance.
  3. Calculate the employer's National Insurance you owe.
  4. Produce payslips. You can use different software for payslips if yours does not do it.
  5. Report pay and deductions to HMRC in a Full Payment Submission on or before pay day.

Include everyone you pay in your payroll records, even if their pay is below the threshold for tax or National Insurance.

Monthly deadlines

Tax months run from the 6th of one month to the 5th of the next. In the following tax month:

  • You can see what you owe online from the 10th.
  • Send an Employer Payment Summary by the 19th to claim any reduction, such as statutory pay or the Employment Allowance.
  • Pay HMRC by the 22nd, or the 19th if paying by post.

If you usually pay less than £1,500 a month, you may be able to pay quarterly. You must send an Employer Payment Summary for any tax month in which you pay no employees. HMRC will close the PAYE scheme of a new employer that sends no report or payment within 120 days.

Pay the software must handle

  • Statutory Sick Pay, and statutory maternity, paternity, adoption, parental bereavement, shared parental and neonatal care pay. These are taxed like normal pay.
  • Bonuses, commission and holiday pay.
  • Tips paid into your till, including tips on card payments.
  • Pension deductions for auto-enrolment.
  • Student loan deductions, from the employee's plan type.

Other pay to record

gov.uk lists other payments to record as normal pay, including:

  • Payments for time an employee spends travelling.
  • Medical and maternity suspension payments.
  • Guarantee payments for a day an employee does not work.
  • Payments to office holders, such as a sports club secretary.
  • Payments that can be turned into cash, such as vouchers or Premium Bonds.
  • Payments made to persuade someone to join.
  • Cash prizes for competitions you run.

Expenses and benefits, such as uniforms or company cars, are reported separately at the end of the tax year.

Late reporting

If you pay employees and send a Full Payment Submission late, or not at all, HMRC sends a late filing notice and can charge a penalty unless you have a valid reason. Late, missing or wrong reports can also affect employees' income-related benefits, such as Universal Credit. Software that reminds you of each pay run helps you stay on time.

Basic PAYE Tools

HMRC's Basic PAYE Tools is free payroll software for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. It works out tax and National Insurance and sends the information to HMRC. You must be registered as an employer and have a PAYE Online login to use it. HMRC says it has some limitations and is not designed for agents. It runs on Windows 10 and 11, recent versions of macOS and Ubuntu Linux.

If your payroll software cannot do certain tasks, you can use Basic PAYE Tools alongside it to check a new employee's National Insurance number or send an Employer Payment Summary.

Pension auto-enrolment

Employers must provide a workplace pension from the day their first member of staff starts. You must enrol and pay into a pension for staff who:

  • Are aged between 22 and State Pension age.
  • Earn at least £10,000 a year.
  • Normally work in the UK.

The employer pays at least 3% of qualifying earnings, which under most schemes are earnings between £6,240 and £50,270 a year. Contributions deducted from pay go to the scheme by the 22nd of the next month, or the 19th by cheque. Every 3 years you re-enrol staff who left the scheme more than 12 months before that date.

If a member of staff becomes eligible because of a change in age or earnings, you must enrol them and write to them within 6 weeks. Each time you carry out re-enrolment you complete a re-declaration of compliance, even if no staff were re-enrolled. You can be fined for paying late, underpaying, or missing the re-declaration.

Example: an employee earns £24,000 a year. Qualifying earnings are £24,000 minus £6,240, which is £17,760. The employer's minimum at 3% is £532.80 a year, or £44.40 a month.

Check whether the software sends contribution figures to your pension scheme, or whether you will send them to the scheme yourself each pay period.

Paying yourself as a director

When you register a limited company online you can register for PAYE in the same service, including when you are the only director and the only person paid. A director's salary then runs through payroll like any other employee's. The salary or dividends guide explains the tax on each.

Questions to ask a provider

  • What does it cost at your number of employees, and at the number you expect next year?
  • Does it send Full Payment Submissions and Employer Payment Summaries to HMRC?
  • Which pension schemes does it send data to?
  • How do employees get payslips?
  • Does it handle statutory pay, student loans and the Employment Allowance claim?
  • Can your accountant log in?

What to compare

FeatureWhat to check
PriceMonthly or yearly, per employee or per band, before or after VAT
Employee limitThe most employees each plan allows
HMRC submissionsFull Payment Submissions and Employer Payment Summaries
PayslipsPrinted, emailed or through an app
Pension linksWhich pension schemes it sends data to
Accounting linkWhether payroll journals post to your accounting software
PlatformOnline, or installed on Windows or Mac

Worked example

Example: a shop has 4 employees on monthly pay. It is registered as an employer and claims the Employment Allowance.

  1. Fewer than 10 employees, so Basic PAYE Tools is an option at no cost.
  2. gov.uk describes Basic PAYE Tools as working out tax and National Insurance and sending it to HMRC. The owner checks how pension contributions would reach the scheme.
  3. A paid product with a pension link and payslips would cost a monthly or yearly fee. Example: £8 a month is £96 a year.
  4. The owner weighs the fee against the time spent on payslips and pension uploads.
  5. Whichever they choose, they send a Full Payment Submission each pay day, an Employer Payment Summary by the 19th to claim the allowance, and pay HMRC by the 22nd.

Checklist

  1. Register as an employer with HMRC before the first pay day.
  2. Count your employees now and in a year's time.
  3. Check each product's price at that headcount.
  4. Check it sends both submissions to HMRC.
  5. Check it links to your pension scheme.
  6. Check how employees get payslips.
  7. Check it posts payroll figures to your accounting software.

Employer costs

The guide to employer National Insurance and the Employment Allowance explains the 15% rate and how to claim the allowance through payroll. The guide to choosing accounting software covers the software that payroll figures post into.

Payroll run for you

The payroll software comparison sets out each product's price and features. If you would like payroll run for you each month, Buzz Accounting offers that service.

Questions

Is there free payroll software?

Yes. HMRC's Basic PAYE Tools is free payroll software for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. It works out tax and National Insurance for your employees and sends the information to HMRC. You must be registered with HMRC as an employer and have a PAYE Online login before you can use it. HMRC says it has some limitations and is not designed for agents. It runs on Windows 10 and 11, recent macOS versions and Ubuntu Linux. If your paid software cannot do certain tasks, Basic PAYE Tools can be used alongside it to check a new employee's National Insurance number or send an Employer Payment Summary. Example: a shop with 4 employees can run its monthly payroll in it at no cost. A business that grows to 10 employees needs other software.

When do I report pay to HMRC?

In a Full Payment Submission on or before each pay day. Every time you pay employees, your payroll software records their pay, works out tax and National Insurance, and sends the submission to HMRC. Include everyone you pay, even if their pay is below the threshold for tax or National Insurance. If you pay no employees in a tax month, send an Employer Payment Summary for that month. Tax months run from the 6th of one month to the 5th of the next. Late or missing reports can lead to a late filing notice and a penalty unless you have a valid reason, and can affect employees' income-related benefits such as Universal Credit. Example: staff paid on 27 November 2026 need a Full Payment Submission sent on or before 27 November.

When do I pay HMRC?

By the 22nd of the next tax month if you pay electronically, or the 19th if you pay by post. You can see what you owe online from the 10th, and you send an Employer Payment Summary by the 19th to claim any reduction, such as statutory pay or the Employment Allowance. If you usually pay HMRC less than £1,500 a month, you may be able to pay quarterly. Contact the payment helpline to find out. Example: for the tax month from 6 November to 5 December 2026, send any Employer Payment Summary by 19 December and pay HMRC by 22 December 2026. HMRC closes the PAYE scheme of a new employer that sends no report or payment within 120 days.

Which staff must I enrol in a pension?

Staff aged between 22 and State Pension age who earn at least £10,000 a year and normally work in the UK, including people based in the UK who travel abroad for work. You must provide a workplace pension from the day your first member of staff starts. If someone becomes eligible because their age or earnings change, you must enrol them and write to them within 6 weeks of the day they meet the criteria. Every 3 years you re-enrol staff who left the scheme more than 12 months before that date, and complete a re-declaration of compliance. Example: an employee earning £18,000 a year turns 22 on 10 March 2027. They must be enrolled, and written to by 21 April 2027.

How much must I pay into the pension?

At least 3% of qualifying earnings, which under most schemes are earnings between £6,240 and £50,270 a year before tax. Total earnings include salary or wages, bonuses and commission, overtime, Statutory Sick Pay and statutory maternity, paternity or adoption pay. Contributions deducted from pay go to the scheme by the 22nd of the next month, or the 19th if you pay by cheque, and you must backdate any missed payments. You can be fined for paying late or below the minimum. Example: an employee earns £24,000 a year. Qualifying earnings are £24,000 minus £6,240, which is £17,760. The employer's minimum at 3% is £532.80 a year, or £44.40 a month.

Sources

Related guides